Decision log
What's decided, what's open
Read straight from the decision tables and open questions in each chapter, so it's always current.
73 decided · 43 open
Decided
Vision16
- Audience
- Played among friends. No business model for now
- Ending
- None. A living world with quests and achievements, no endgame
- Player role
- Free choice of settling, adventuring, crafting, fighting and trading
- Progression
- Classless, use-based skills with a soft cap: unused skills decay slowly. Abilities are learned techniques in 6 slots. See mechanics
- Professions
- Open to everyone, no lock-in
- Combat
- Action, skill-based
- Tone
- Epic high fantasy
- PvP
- Three risk tiers: safe Accord towns, guarded lanes and home isles (consensual PvP), open wild isles
- Death
- Partial loot drop: carried resources drop, equipped gear is kept (and loses durability)
- Scale
- Small shards, about 50–200 concurrent players per world
- Shards
- Characters and markets are shared across shards; players can move between them
- Travel
- Bridges and paths between nearby isles; crafted sailships (enchanted sails, wind currents) for longer routes and cargo
- Housing
- Rented personal plots in safe towns, with a house, crafting stations, storage and a dock. Guild property is decided with social
- World premise
- Floating isles above the drowned old world. Why they float is unknown; isles are slowly sinking. See world
- Ships
- Can be attacked; cargo can be looted. Realistic sail simulation on enchanted wind currents
- Technology
- Pure high fantasy; ships sail on enchanted sails and wind currents
How You Play · Mechanics18
- Progression
- Use-based skills, 0–100 each. Soft cap with decay: no hard total cap; unused skills decay slowly and never below half their peak, so returning to an old skill is fast
- Everything is a skill
- No separation between magic and other skills. Wind magic, swordplay, cooking and sailing all work the same way
- Resources
- No mana. One stamina bar for everything (swinging, casting, dodging, sprinting), refilling quickly at rest. Strong techniques also have their own cooldowns
- Learning
- Skills are learned at a source: a trainer, a book, or a place tied to the skill. At 75 a player can become a trainer; at 100 they can write books that teach the skill
- Skill count
- A fixed list of shared skills across combat, magic, gathering, crafting and travel (see skills), plus one innate skill per people
- Abilities
- Learned techniques from trainers and books, unlocked at skill thresholds. 6 technique slots, swapped outside combat
- Controls
- Hybrid: free-aim attacks by default, with an optional soft lock-on toggle (good for gamepad)
- Risk zones
- Three tiers, see below
- Death
- Carried resources drop at the death spot for a while; equipped gear stays but loses durability. Respawn at the nearest Accord shrine
- Crafting
- Simple recipes: recipe plus materials makes an item; skill sets the success chance and quality roll
- Group PvE
- Sinking-isle events and world bosses from storm surges. See monsters
- Sinking
- Slowed by Treetending the ancient trees (a skill anyone can learn); a sinking isle can't be saved. Rare isle births add new land as world events
- Gear
- Wears down with use, as well as on death. Worn gear is repaired by crafters or replaced
- Ships
- Three sizes; can be attacked and cargo looted. Sails wear from attacks, weather and distance travelled. See sailing
- Quests and achievements
- Quests give direction and story; achievements record what a character has done. No endgame. See quests
- Gear tiers
- Set by material; crafting skill sets the quality within a tier. See economy
- First hours
- Start in your people's homeland. See first hours
- Long-term goals
- Mastery and rare techniques, rare drowned-world relic gear, ships and trade empires, reputation and customization
Economy and Crafting · Economy9
- Gear source
- Crafting first. Monsters mostly drop materials, recipes and books. Finished gear drops are rare and still need crafters to repair
- Gear tiers
- Set by material: each material entry gives its family and tier. Crafting skill sets quality within a tier
- Housing
- Town plots are rented weekly with gold. If rent stops, after a warning the plot is freed and its contents go to storage
- Currency
- Single gold currency
- Markets
- Local order books per town. Each town's book is the same on every shard: Windmarket's orders are shared by Windmarket on all shards. Goods still have to be hauled there on the shard you're on. Prices differ between towns, not between shards
- Gear wear
- Gear wears down with use, which keeps crafters in demand
- Knowledge
- Player trainers and player-written books are traded like goods
- Gold sinks
- Gear durability and repair, town plot rent and upkeep, sail wear from attacks, weather and distance
- Cargo
- Ship cargo can be looted when a ship is attacked
Creatures · Monsters12
- Tone
- Mostly natural creatures that behave like animals. Storm-touched versions, twisted by the storm below, are more dangerous
- Temperament
- Each creature has one: passive (flees), neutral (fights back), territorial (attacks if you come close) or hostile (hunts you). Storm-touched creatures are always hostile
- Difficulty
- Set by risk tier: weaker creatures on safe and guarded isles, the strongest on wild isles and the rim. A creature's strength is fixed by its kind, since characters have no levels
- Readability
- Danger is readable: size, look and a danger mark show how strong a creature is compared to your skills. Storm surges are the only surprise
- Day and night
- Some creatures only come out at night, or behave differently after dark
- Seasons
- Flocks and herds migrate between isles with the seasons
- Flying creatures
- Some attack ships in the air, not just players on isles
- Populations
- Each isle has a population of each creature that refills over time. Overhunting thins it out for a while, so hunters move on
- Taming
- A Taming skill turns some creatures into ground mounts, pack animals or flying mounts
- World bosses
- Rise from the storm during storm surges at wild isles, announced shortly before. They scale with how many players are nearby
- Boss loot
- Everyone who helped gets their own reward. A bonus drop lands on the ground for players to fight over
- Relics
- From sinking isles, world bosses, solo and small-group dives into the drowned world, and ruins on newborn isles
Art Direction · Kit reference sheets8
- One spec
- Every kit sheet follows this page. Prompts are composed from the templates below, not written out by hand
- Background
- Plain light neutral grey, no scene, no sky, no floating rock. Only a soft contact shadow under each piece
- Light
- Flat, even studio light with no cast shadows and no rim light. Warm gold and cool teal stay as painted colour, never as baked lighting, because textures are unlit (art direction)
- Scale figure
- A plain human silhouette at true scale on every sheet that shows size: 1.8 m by default, or the height of the people the kit is built for (Anchorkin 2.6 m, Galeborne 1.9 m, Rootwardens 1.6 m)
- Labels
- Reference sheets carry small neat labels and dimensions. Sheets that go straight into Meshy (base bodies, single parts) carry no text at all
- Location
- Kit sheets in art/kit/<kind>/, each with a .json sidecar of the same name
- Textures
- One trim sheet per kit; every piece of the kit maps onto it (modular kit)
- Detail
- Detail is painted, not modelled. Shapes stay chunky and readable as a silhouette
Art Direction10
- Rendering
- Stylized painterly: hand-painted textures, soft lighting, gentle rim light
- Camera
- Third-person, over the shoulder
- Characters
- Heroic stylized proportions: slightly larger hands, heads and shoulders, readable silhouettes at distance
- Reference use
- The reference anchors the palette and mood; other elements stay open to exploration
- 3D fidelity
- Hand-painted, mid detail: chunky readable shapes, with detail painted into textures rather than modelled
- Peoples
- Near-human peoples, each with a signature trait that always reads (see character customization), not beast-folk. The animal-folk look was retired with the earlier peoples (see peoples)
- Colour and light
- Softer and more muted than the first tests: gentler saturation, painterly atmosphere. The palette below is applied at lower saturation
- Texture lighting
- Flat, unlit colour textures (Meshy 7.1). Painterly lighting comes from in-engine shaders, not baked into textures (lighting test)
- Time
- Day and night cycle and four seasons, changing light, colour and foliage
- Character concept format
- Turnaround sheets (front, side, back) on a neutral background, used as input for Meshy image-to-3D
Open questions
Vision1
- How many town plots per shard.
The World · World3
- What the storm is: a force of nature, something sleeping, or the old world's doing? Players may never fully learn.
- How storm surges play out: creature waves, faster sinking, blocked wind lanes.
- What sank Vael? The Ledger has an entry for it, but the stone is broken. That could be a long-term mystery.
Peoples · Character Customization4
- How many preset heads and slider ranges per people?
- Can appearance be changed after creation, and at what cost (a barber or mask-maker as a gold sink)?
- Gender and body variation per people: one base with sliders, or a second base per family?
- Which signature traits are tied to progression, and which are free from the start?
Peoples3
- Home towns within each homeland beyond the shrine isle.
- Male, female and body variation for each people.
- Exact numbers for each innate skill (glide distance, anchor hold time, regeneration rate).
How You Play · Mechanics7
- Exact decay rate, and whether the "half of peak" floor is per skill.
- How fast skills rise, and which actions grant gains (anti-macro rules).
- Technique counts per tree.
- Whether written books carry their author's name.
- Which sources teach which skills, and whether some skills can only be learned in certain places.
- Base sinking cadence per shard, and how much tending slows it.
- How often isles are born, and what triggers the birth.
Sailing3
- Ship combat weapons (spells, bows, boarding) and how a ship is disabled.
- Can ships themselves be destroyed or captured, or only their cargo taken?
- Cargo capacity per ship, and crafting costs.
Economy and Crafting · Economy3
- How are skill books priced and copied: one book per copy, written by hand?
- Should there be any market tax? Not chosen yet; the sinks above are expected to carry the load.
- The exact material tiers, and how fast gear wears through durability.
Creatures · Monsters5
- Final names and looks, after concept art.
- The crag drake: the first bestiary draft called it a small drake, but its entry makes it large (420 health, nests on the highest spires). Which is it?
- How often storm surges happen, and how much warning players get.
- Flying mount limits (above).
- How dangerous dives into the drowned world are, and how long they last.
Simulation4
- Exact radii and rates per level, tuned against real server load.
- How bots pick what to do in the economy without crashing prices.
- Whether NPCs on sinking isles evacuate as part of the event.
- How bot characters present to players: named, with gear and reputation, or clearly marked as NPCs.
Art Direction · Biomes3
- Weather per biome: wind streaks and snow on crags, mist in forests, drizzle and storm flashes at the lagoons?
- Do biomes blend on large isles, or does each isle keep one biome?
- How strongly should newborn isles differ from established ones in the same biome?
Art Direction · Kit reference sheets4
- Are the creature and ship budgets right? Check them against the first rigged creature and the first ship in the engine.
- Is 1024 px enough for a kit trim sheet seen up close in towns, or do Accord towns need 2048 px?
- Should every piece sheet also carry a small silhouette row (pieces as black shapes) to check readability on the sheet itself?
- Do dressed characters need their own turnaround type, separate from creatures, once outfits are modelled?
Art Direction3
- How each season looks, weather, and how the sky looks below the isles
- UI style: parchment and gold, or minimal glass
- Visual identity for each biome and isle type: drafted in Biomes